• x remembers phi 
• x remembers phi at t 
• x now has phenomminological recovery at phi ing at t1 
• if there is an xt, such that xt1 phd and x now is x at t1 
• this leads to a circularity 
• xt1 phid 
• there is an appropriate causal chain from x at t1 phing at x now having phenomenal memory 
• memory depends on bodily continuity 
• who is julia ? 
• is she her when she is given a different brain but the same body 
• is this a brain transplant 
• or a body transplant 
• suppose we take sergio and take half of his brain out and put it in someones body 
• and freeze the rest of him 
•